Competition heating up

Among the responses to this blog:

There is the comment shown below. Eclipse is the main competition to
IDEA, so this is going to put a certain amount of pressure on JetBrains
to make progress on their plug-in.

I was looking at some Scala source code from the Lift framework and I
was disappointed at the number of red marks I saw.



Posted February 21, 2011 at 4:17 pm | Permalink

This is Martin, the language designer. I am sorry that your tool
experience was so frustrating.

I just wanted to say that my company Scala Solutions has taken the over
development of the Eclipse IDE for Scala. We should have a first beta
out together with the release of Scala 2.9, in a couple of weeks. I have
personally spent quite a lot of time improving the interface with the
compiler. I have now switched for all of my development work to our as
yet unreleased version of the Scala plugin for Eclipse. That’s after 20
years of emacs. And I am not looking back.

The new Eclipse IDE is not yet as feature complete as Java’s, but we
have made great progress in terms of stability and responsiveness in
large projects.

Comment actions Permalink

Competition is good and if it spurs JetBrains to put more resources into its Scala work, I'll applaud that. As far as Scala support goes, Eclipse has a lot of catching up to do.

But Eclipse is inferior in every way and I'll never use it. It made such a bad impression the first time I tried, I simply have no interest in using it for anything.

Randall Schulz

Comment actions Permalink

i think this is good. the more ides support scala properly, the better. scala should spread.

Comment actions Permalink

... and the more people will use IntelliJ Scala plugin, so it's a win-win situation ;)


Please sign in to leave a comment.