complaining about IDEA's UI

I do not want to sound rude - so first let me congratulate to the fresh IDEA 5.0 ;)

... but: Am I the only one who thinks the UI is a partially a little bit uglyish / or at least somehow space-wasting?

e.g. see idea.jpg: I do not like the big border around the textfield inside the combobox.

see idea2.jpg: why the big borders everywhere?

I'm quite sure you know the style guide from JGoodies about redundant borders etc.

... could be improved, IMHO

Bye,
M.



Attachment(s):
idea.jpg
idea2.jpg
6 comments
Comment actions Permalink

I haven't yet began to use Irida. Still judging from the few test runs the Alloy IDEA theme is not that 'space wasting'. You can always 'fall back' to old Pallada theme if you like.

0
Comment actions Permalink

IMHO space wasting has always been a big problem in Idea (e.g. : the tab
bar)

BoD

Michael Damberger wrote:

I do not want to sound rude - so first let me congratulate to the fresh IDEA 5.0 ;)

0
Comment actions Permalink

ah yes, indeed - I was not aware that the L&F could be changed - thanks for the information. I'll try it with the IDEA4.5 default ;)

Sureley I like the combobox from that L&F better.


Bye,
M.

0
Comment actions Permalink

Funnily enough, the tab bar is one thing that's been changed in IDEA 5 (at least on my screen) to make better use of space. Thanks for that!

One the other hand, I tend to agree with the comments about borders. Certainly Karsten (JGoodies) is the guru master of Java UI asthetics. His "metamorphosis" demo application is a classic.

John Hurst
Wellington, New Zealand

0
Comment actions Permalink

In my experience, the skin has a huge effect on the amount of space wasted. Tabs are a good example where you can see this. The Idea 4.5 skin as FAR more space efficient than the Motif skin. Although you can trim down the space the Motif skin uses by adjusting it's font.

0

Please sign in to leave a comment.