Formatting problems

Since I've switched to Irida, I haven't managed to get it to format my code quite how I like. This used to work fine in 4.5.3. I had my indent/continuation indent set at 4/4, which would give me:

public class Foo
implements Bar
{
...
}

Now with those settings, sometimes it works, and sometimes I get:

public class Foo
implements Bar
{
...
}

and even wierder, occasionally I'll get (for accessor methods:

public String name()
{
return NAME;
}

The only way I can get it to behave reliably is to set the continuation indent to 0, in which case I get:

public class Foo
implements Bar
{
...
}

Not terrible, but not what I want either. Is there a new option I haven't set? Or am I doing something wrong?