CLion file search has inconsistent ordering

When searching for Files in CLion the order of the results are inconsistent.

Example:
A test project has 3 files named “test_file_001.h”, “test_file_002.h” and “test_file_here.h”.
Searching for “test_fi” makes “test_file_001.h” the first among the results but typing “test_fil” makes “test_file_here.h” the first.
With larger projects with many files having similar prefixes this makes for a bad guessing game on how the result will look like.

I see no logic behind the order and it makes it hard to select the correct result quickly because as you are typing you see the first result as the one you are looking for and hit enter to select it but because many of us are fast typers the next letter is already inputted and the result list becomes scambled.

How do I turn off this “feature”?